Menu
Discover authentic handcrafted Sundaes, Concretes, Splits, Shakes, Malts, Smoothies, Frozen Custard, Signature Coffee, Frappes, Nitro Coffee, Hot Chocolate, Floats, Freezes, Fresh Squeezed Lemonade and Limeade, Custom Creations and All Natural Gourmet Soda’s on Tap!
SUNDAES
Artisanal, Fresh & Hand Crafted-
Royal Turtle
Vanilla frozen custard, caramel, hot fudge, roasted pecans, topped with a cherry
one size $5.80
-
Lone Star
Vanilla frozen custard, strawberries, sliced banana & hot fudge
one size $5.80
-
Salted Caramel Brownie
Vanilla frozen custard, double chocolate brownie, caramel, topped with mineral-rich French sea salt and a cherry
$5.80
-
Mango Tango
Vanilla frozen custard, sweet mango, roasted pecans, toasted coconut, topped with a cherry
one size $5.80
-
Molten Lava
Vanilla frozen custard, molten cake, hot fudge, topped with a cherry
one size $5.80
-
Tin Roof
Vanilla frozen custard, chocolate syrup, roasted peanuts, creamy peanut butter, topped with a cherry
one size $5.80
-
Create Your Own
Vanilla or chocolate frozen custard, your choice of one topping, and a cherry (extra charge for additional toppings)
One Size $4.60
THE SPLITS
-
Banana Split
3 scoops of vanilla frozen custard and a whole banana covered with strawberries, pineapples, hot fudge, topped with marshmallow creme, roasted pecans and 3 cherries
one size $6.70
-
R & B
2 scoops of vanilla frozen custard and a whole warm chocolate lava bundt cake covered with hot fudge and raspberries
one size $7.10
-
Natural Cookie
3 scoops of vanilla frozen custard, fresh baked all-natural double chocolate cookie with sea salt and chocolate chunks, sliced bananas, caramel drizzle and 3 cherries
one size $6.70
SHAKES & MALTS
You can not get a better Shake or Malt anywhere! The best requires premium ingredients & we've got you covered! 12oz | 16oz | 24oz-
The Nutella®
This is just NUTS! The Nutella® shake is on a whole nutter level. Don’t say we didn’t warn you!
sm $4.20
md $4.80
lg $5.20
-
Toasted Coconut
Real coconut flakes toasted daily and mixed with our classic vanilla, topped with whipped cream.
sm $4.20
md $4.80
lg $5.20
-
Campfire Marshmallow
Campfire favorite mixed with classic vanilla, topped with whipped cream and toasted marshmallow.
sm $4.20
md $4.80
lg $5.20
-
Horchata
(Pronunciation: or-CHAH-tah) Traditional Mexican beverage featuring rice milk and cinnamon is the “out of the box” must try.
sm $4.20
md $4.80
lg $5.20
-
Chocolate Berry
Ripe blackberries and strawberries to be exact paired with chocolate chunks make this perfect combination.
sm $4.20
md $4.80
lg $5.20
-
Chocolate Malt
Only the best Chocolate Malt you will ever have! Really! Let the challenge begin!
sm $4.20
md $4.80
lg $5.20
-
Banana Cream
Made with whole bananas and topped with whipped cream.
sm $4.20
md $4.80
lg $5.20
-
Snickerdoodle
A sweet cream base with just a touch of cinnamon blended with cookie flavoring!
sm $4.20
md $4.80
lg $5.20
-
Peaches & Cream
Ripe sweet juicy peaches topped with whipped cream!
sm $4.20
md $4.80
lg $5.20
-
Create Your Own
Vanilla or chocolate or mixed frozen custard, your choice of one topping (extra charge for additional toppings)
sm $4.20
md $4.80
lg $5.20
COLD SIGNATURE COFFEE
*FRAPPES* A frappe (pronounced frap-pay) is an iced beverage that has been blended to produce a tasty, refreshing, slushy consistency type drink.-
Pure Vanilla Frappe
Rich espresso, all-natural vanilla syrup and fresh made vanilla custard, blended with ice then topped with whipped cream
sm $3.95
md $4.75
lg $5.25
-
Fudge & Espresso Frappe
Rich espresso, premium hot fudge and fresh made vanilla custard, blended with ice then topped with whipped cream
sm $3.95
md $4.75
lg $5.25
-
Caramel Dulce Frappe
Rich espresso, premium caramel and fresh made vanilla custard, blended with ice then topped with whipped cream
sm $3.95
md $4.75
lg $5.25
-
Loaded Mocha Frappe
Rich espresso, premium hot fudge, almonds, Heath® and fresh made vanilla custard, blended with ice then topped with whipped cream
sm $3.95
md $4.75
lg $5.25
-
Cold Brews
Made with our signature slow-steeped 24 hours cold brew. Topped with Whipped Cream. Your Choice: MOCHA, CINNAMON CHAI, COCONUT CREAM, VANILLA, CARAMEL
sm $4.00
md $4.50
lg $5.00
-
Nitro Coffee
Our NITRO is infused with nitrogen as it pours for the tap. Nitrogen infusion creates micro bubbles, giving the coffee a cascading frothy texture resulting in a velvety-smooth coffee with a subtly sweet flavor and a rich, creamy head of foam.
sm $4.30
md $4.80
lg $5.30
-
Vanilla Cream Nitro Coffee
Vanilla and creamy sweet cream added to our from the tap nitrogen infused NITRO. Nitrogen infusion creates micro bubbles, giving the coffee a cascading frothy texture resulting in a velvety-smooth coffee with a subtly sweet flavor and a rich, creamy head of foam.
sm $4.50
md $5.00
lg $5.50
-
Classic Affogato
Sweet ice cream meets hot roasted espresso making this the quintessential Italian dessert, with a pinch of chocolate and a sprinkling of sea salt.
one size $3.20
-
Caramel Affogato
Over the top! Our classic Affogato topped with caramel. A touch of sweet and creamy makes this the perfect smooth balance.
one size $3.50
DRINKS
-
Fresh Squeezed Lemonade
Our one-of-a-kind fresh lemonade... made with pressed sugarcane juice and fresh squeezed lemons. We make our lemonades and limeades from fresh lemons and limes in house every day.
sm $3.00
md $3.50
lg $4.00
-
Fresh Squeezed Cherry Lime-Ade
Fresh-squeezed limes added with cherries. We make our lemonades and limeades from fresh lemons and limes in house every day.
sm $3.00
md $3.50
lg $4.00
-
Float or Freeze
Made with award winning handcrafted caffeine free sodas. Fire-brewed, local Ingredients, caffeine free, gluten free SELECT: OLD FASHIONED ROOT BEER, ORANGE DREAM, CHERRY KOLA, CREAM SODA, CRANBERRY-CHERRY
md $4.60
lg $5.60
-
Hot Chocolate
With whipped cream. We make our hot chocolate in-house using J’s secret recipe. It’s thicker, richer and more decadent than your usual hot chocolate. This is the hot chocolate that all others will be compared to.
sm $3.50
md $4.10
lg $4.50
-
Frozen Hot Chocolate
With whipped cream. Just one sip of our creamy, dreamy, icy blend of chocolatey goodness and the love affair will begin. This is sure to be one of our best kept secrets. 16 oz
one size $4.80
CONCRETES
Handcrafting & customizing our frozen custard into concretes, we push the boundaries of what frozen desserts can be. Creaminess and consistent texture is what we are known for.-
Dirt & Worms
Vanilla frozen custard, Oreos®, topped with chocolate sprinkles and gummy worms
sm $4.64
md $5.50
lg $6.44
-
Mint Chip
Vanilla frozen custard, mint, chocolate flakes, Oreos®
sm $4.64
md $5.50
lg $6.44
-
Chocolate Kiss
1/2 chocolate & 1/2 vanilla frozen custard, chocolate flakes and cookie dough
sm $4.64
md $5.50
lg $6.44
-
Wedding Cake
Vanilla frozen custard and a slice of wedding cake
sm $4.64
md $5.50
lg $6.44
-
German Chocolate
Chocolate frozen custard, caramel, chocolate flakes, toasted coconut, pecans
sm $5.54
md $6.44
lg $7.34
-
Cinnamon Churro
Vanilla frozen custard, blended with cinnamon sugar churro and caramel
sm $4.64
md $5.50
lg $6.44
-
Mocha Almond
Chocolate frozen custard, 24-hr cold steep espresso, almonds
sm $4.84
md $5.74
lg $6.44
-
Classic Cheesecake
Vanilla frozen custard, slice of cheesecake, choice of standard topping
md $5.74
lg $6.64
-
Blackberry Brownie
Vanilla frozen custard, blackberries, chocolate brownie
sm $4.84
md $5.74
lg $6.64
-
Lemon Lush
Vanilla frozen custard, blended with a whole piece of sweet creamy lemon bar
sm $4.84
md $5.74
lg $6.64
-
Create Your Own Concrete
Vanilla or chocolate or mixed frozen custard, your choice of one topping (extra charge for additional toppings)
sm $3.89
md $4.79
lg $5.69
SMOOTHIES
We create our smoothies with real fruit, ice and go over the top with our all natural frozen custard making these a smooth healthy delicious option. 12 oz | 24 oz-
Strawberry Banana
Fresh premium vanilla frozen custard, fresh strawberries and a whole banana blended with ice
sm $2.80
lg $5.60
-
Pina Colada
Fresh premium vanilla frozen custard, fresh pineapple, coconut, blended with ice
sm $2.80
lg $5.60
-
Raspberry Lemonade
Fresh premium vanilla frozen custard, fresh raspberries and hand squeezed lemons blended with ice
sm $2.80
lg $5.60
-
Strawberry Peach
Fresh premium vanilla frozen custard, fresh peaches and strawberries, blended with ice
sm $2.80
lg $5.60
-
Orange Peach
Fresh premium vanilla frozen custard, orange juice and sweet peaches, blended with ice
sm $2.80
lg $5.60
FROZEN CUSTARD
-
2 scoops | 3 scoops | 4 scoops | 5 scoops
Fresh premium vanilla, chocolate or mixed scoops in cake cone or cup
2 scoops $2.10
3 scoops $2.60
4 scoops $3.20
5 scoops $3.70
-
Cup + Topping
Fresh premium vanilla, chocolate or mixed scoops and your favorite topping(s) FRUIT, CANDY, PREMIUM add .80 SUPER PREMIUM add 1.20
-
FRESH MADE WAFFLE CONE
Fresh premium vanilla, chocolate or mixed scoops
2 scoops $3.30
3 scoops $3.80
4 scoops $3.20
5 scoops $3.70
-
Baby Cone
BABY CONE FREE with a purchase (available for under 5 yrs old, 1 per child) Fresh premium vanilla or chocolate frozen custard
-
Puppy Cone
PUPPY CONE FREE with a purchase (4 legged family members, 1 per pet) Fresh premium vanilla frozen custard
CUSTOM CREATIONS
J’s Frozen Custard is made to order, in minutes, right before your eyes. Mix and match to create your own. Starting with CHOCOLATE OR VANILLA-
Create Your Own Concrete
Mix and match to create your own. Your choice of one topping(s). Extra charge for additional toppings. CHOCOLATE OR VANILLA OR MIX
9 oz $3.89
12 oz $4.79
16 oz $5.69
-
Create Your Own Sundae
Mix and match to create your own. Your choice of one topping(s). Extra charge for additional toppings. CHOCOLATE OR VANILLA OR MIX
one size $4.60
-
Create Your Own Shake or Malt
Mix and match to create your own. Your choice of one topping(s). Extra charge for additional toppings. CHOCOLATE OR VANILLA OR MIX
9 oz $4.20
12 oz $4.80
16 oz $5.20
-
Create Your Own Smoothie
Your choice of 2 fruits
12 oz $2.00
24 oz $4.80
PREMUIM TOPPINGS
Butterfinger®️, Chocolate Chip, Chocolate Sprinkles, Cookie Dough, Graham Cracker, Gummy Worms, Heath®️, M & M's®️, Oreos®️, Peanut Butter Cups, Pretzels, Rainbow Sprinkles, Rice Krispies®️, Snickers®️, Butterscotch, Caramel, Chocolate Syrup, Hot Fudge, Marshmallow Cream, Peanut Butter, Whipped Cream, Blackberries, Blueberries, Coconut-Toasted, Mangos, Maraschino Cherries, Peaches, Pineapples, Raspberries, StrawberriesSUPER PREMIUM TOPPINGS
Almonds, Brownie, Espresso, Roasted Peanuts, Roasted Pecans, Seasonal Pies & CobblersFIRE-BREWED GOURMET SODA’S ON TAP
Fire-brewed, local Ingredients, caffeine free, gluten free 12 oz | 16 oz | 24 oz-
Old Fashioned Root Beer
This truly old fashioned soda has the rich, creamy flavor that only comes from using pure Wisconsin honey direct from the combs. Extracts are prepared in the brewery in a hand-made, gas-fired brew kettle, by combing honey, pure vanilla and hosts of aromatic botanicals. Caffine free.
$2.00
$2.50
$3.00
-
Orange Dream
Enjoy this super citrus drink of natural orange flavors, honey and vanilla for a creamy, dreamy taste experience that’s over the moon. Caffine free.
$2.00
$2.50
$3.00
-
Cranberry-Cherry
The natural essence of cherries and cranberries is skillfully simmered with pure honey for a soft drink that is the perfect balance of tart and sweet.
$2.00
$2.50
$3.00
-
Cherry Kola
Sprecher Cherry Cola is a masterful blend of wisconsin’s own Door County cherry juice, raw joney, the finest cola extract, and a handful of select spices cooked to perfection.
$2.00
$2.50
$3.00
-
Cream Soda
Another throw-back to the standards of yesteryear, This cream soda is honey colored, not colorless or artificially red. Wisconsin honey and pure vanilla are carefully blended in a fusion of flavor.
$2.00
$2.50
$3.00
PIE MENU
SERVES 10-12 PEOPLE-
ROYAL TURTLE
Oreo Pie Shell, Hot Fudge, Chopped Pecans, Vanilla Frozen Custard, Whole Pecans, Caramel, Whole Cherry
$21.00
-
MEGA MINT
Oreo Pie Shell, Hot Fudge, Oreo Pieces, Vanilla Frozen Custard, Whole Oreo Cookies, Green Peppermint Syrup, Grasshopper Cookies
$21.00
-
MUD PUDDLE
Oreo Pie Shell, Peanut Butter, Vanilla Frozen Custard, Reeses's Peanut Butter Cup Pieces, Hot Fudge
$21.00
-
DIRT & WORMS
Oreo Pie Shell, Hot Fudge, Oreo Pieces, Vanilla Frozen Custard, Oreo Crumbs, Gummi Worms
$21.00
-
COOKIE DOUGH
Oreo Pie Shell, Hot Fudge, Chocolate Chip, Vanilla Frozen Custard, Cookie Dough
$21.00
-
BROWNIE SUNDAE
Oreo Pie Shell, Hot Fudge, Marshmallow, Brownies, Vanilla Frozen Custard, Pecans
$21.00
-
BUTTER PECAN
Graham Cracker Pie Shell, Vanilla Frozen Custard, Butterscotch, Chopped Pecans, Whole Pecans
$21.00
-
GERMAN CHOCOLATE
Oreo Pie Shell, Caramel, Chopped Pecans, Chocolate Frozen Custard, Coconut, Hot Fudge
$21.00
-
SEASONAL PUMPKIN PIE
Graham Cracker Pie Shell, Caramel, Vanilla Frozen Custard, Pumpkin Pie
$21.00
-
SEASONAL CANDY CANE
Oreo Pie Shell, Hot Fudge, Mini Candy Canes, Vanilla Frozen Custard, Candy Cane Pillows, Peppermint Flakes, Chocolate Chips, Peppermint Flakes, Whole Cherry
$21.00